Silicone Freezer Trays for Soup, Sauce and Baby Food
The Souper Cubes 2 Cup Silicone Freezer Tray suits most households, using molded volume markings to portion soup and stock without guesswork. Parents making baby food do better with the OXO Tot tray, while anyone on a tight budget fits well with the WeeSprout multi-pack.
The Souper Cubes 2 Cup Silicone Freezer Tray leads this list because its molded cup markings turn leftover soup or sauce into pre-measured portions without a separate measuring cup. Its main limitation is bulk, since four large cavities take up more freezer shelf space than smaller trays.
We compared cavity volume, lid attachment and silicone grade across product listings and owner feedback rather than freezing a batch in each tray ourselves.
Our top picks
Souper Cubes 2 Cup Silicone Freezer Tray
Four large cavities hold two cups each, with volume lines molded directly into the silicone so portions stay consistent without a measuring cup. Food-grade silicone flexes enough to pop out frozen cubes without running the tray under water first. A silicone lid snaps over the top to stop freezer odors from reaching the contents.
Pros
- Molded volume lines remove the need for a separate measuring cup
- Flexible silicone pops out frozen cubes without running water over the tray
- Snap-on lid blocks freezer odor from transferring into stored food
Cons
- Large 2-cup cavities take up more freezer shelf space than smaller trays
- Only four cavities per tray means more trays needed for bigger batches
OXO Tot Baby Food Freezer Tray
Six small cavities hold roughly one ounce each, sized for single baby food servings rather than family portions. An attached hinged lid covers the whole tray at once, so there is no separate lid to misplace in a drawer. BPA-free silicone stays soft enough to twist gently and release each cube.
Pros
- Attached hinged lid cannot get lost or separated from the tray
- Small 1-ounce cavities match typical baby food serving sizes
- Soft silicone twists easily to pop out frozen portions
Cons
- Six small cavities fill up quickly for batch cooking larger quantities
- Not sized for adult portions like soup or sauce
WeeSprout Silicone Freezer Tray
A two-tray pack gives twice the cavities for close to the cost of a single premium tray elsewhere. Each cavity holds about two tablespoons, suited to purees and small sauce portions rather than full meals. A clip-on lid locks onto each tray separately so one can stay in use while the other freezes.
Pros
- Two trays included cost less per cavity than single-tray competitors
- Separate clip-on lids let one tray freeze while the other is in use
- Small cavities suit purees and sauce portions well
Cons
- Clips can loosen with repeated washing over many months
- Cavities are too small for soup or stock portions
Bentgo Baby Silicone Freezer Tray
A stackable shape lets two filled trays sit on top of each other without crushing a flexible lid underneath. Eight cavities hold about an ounce each, a size that matches single daycare meal portions. The silicone resists staining from tomato-based purees better than some softer competing trays.
Pros
- Stackable design saves freezer space when storing multiple trays
- Stain-resistant silicone holds up to tomato-based purees
- Portion size matches typical single daycare meal servings
Cons
- Lid fit is tighter than some trays, taking more effort to seal
- Limited to one portion size across all cavities
Olababy Silicone Freezer Tray
A raised base under each cavity lets a finger push food out from below instead of only squeezing the tray walls. This helps smooth purees release cleanly without sticking to cavity corners. A clip-on lid fits snugly enough to prevent leaks during transport to a freezer shelf.
Pros
- Push-out base design releases smooth purees cleanly
- Clip-on lid seals tightly enough to prevent leaks in transit
- Soft silicone stays flexible even after repeated freeze cycles
Cons
- Six cavities limit batch size for larger cooking sessions
- Push-out base adds a slightly thicker profile than flat-bottom trays
Haakaa Silicone Freezer Tray
A slim, low-profile shape fits freezer door shelves that taller trays cannot clear. Soft, pliable silicone releases frozen cubes with a gentle twist rather than a hard squeeze. The brand’s reputation for food-safe silicone in its breast pump line carries over to this tray’s material quality.
Pros
- Low-profile shape clears tight freezer door shelves
- Soft silicone releases cubes with a gentle twist, not a hard squeeze
- Established silicone quality from the brand’s wider baby product line
Cons
- Comes without a dedicated lid in some bundle versions
- Smaller overall capacity than two-tray multi-packs
Zorestar Silicone Baby Food Freezer Tray
This tray mixes smaller one-ounce cavities with a few larger two-ounce cavities on the same mold. That split suits a household feeding both a baby and an older toddler from one freezer tray. A hinged lid stays attached to the tray edge so it will not slide off during stacking.
Pros
- Mixed cavity sizes suit feeding more than one age group at once
- Hinged lid stays attached rather than becoming a separate loose piece
- Handles both thin purees and chunkier mashed portions
Cons
- Mixed cavity sizes make uniform batch portions harder to plan
- Larger cavities take slightly longer to freeze solid than small ones
The lineup, side by side
| # | Model | Material | Best for | Score | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Souper Cubes 2 Cup Silicone Freezer Tray | Food-grade silicone | Best Overall | 9.2 | Check price |
| 2 | OXO Tot Baby Food Freezer Tray | BPA-free silicone | Best for Baby Food | 9.0 | Check price |
| 3 | WeeSprout Silicone Freezer Tray | Silicone | Best Value Multi-Pack | 8.7 | Check price |
| 4 | Bentgo Baby Silicone Freezer Tray | Food-grade silicone | Best for Daycare Portions | 8.6 | Check price |
| 5 | Olababy Silicone Freezer Tray | 100% food-grade silicone | Best for Smooth Purees | 8.5 | Check price |
| 6 | Haakaa Silicone Freezer Tray | Food-grade silicone | Best Compact Pick | 8.4 | Check price |
| 7 | Zorestar Silicone Baby Food Freezer Tray | BPA-free silicone | Best for Mixed Portion Sizes | 8.3 | Check price |
How to choose
What to look for in a silicone freezer tray Cavity size decides what the tray is actually for, with one-ounce cavities suited to baby food and two-cup cavities built for soup or stock. Lid style matters just as much, since an attached hinged lid cannot get lost while a separate clip-on lid can seal a bit tighter. Food-grade, BPA-free silicone is standard across reputable brands, but softer silicone tends to release frozen cubes with less effort.
Trays for baby food versus trays for adult portions A tray like the OXO Tot or Olababy fits baby food, with small cavities sized for single servings a parent spoons straight from freezer to bowl. The Souper Cubes tray targets adult cooking instead, turning a big batch of soup or sauce into cup-sized portions for weeknight reheating. Mixing the two uses in one tray, as the Zorestar tray does with dual cavity sizes, works for households feeding a baby and an older child from the same batch.
Daycare, travel and stacking needs Parents sending food to daycare benefit from a stackable tray with a secure lid, since Bentgo Baby’s design keeps portions from leaking during transport. A slim, low-profile tray like Haakaa’s clears a tight freezer door shelf that bulkier trays cannot fit into. Multi-pack trays such as WeeSprout’s two-tray set let one tray stay in the freezer while a second tray gets washed and refilled.
Release and cleaning tips that extend tray life Letting a filled tray sit at room temperature for a minute or two before attempting to pop out cubes reduces strain on the silicone walls. Pushing from underneath a cavity, rather than only squeezing the sides, protects raised push-out designs like Olababy’s from tearing over time. Hand washing occasionally instead of every load through a dishwasher can slow down how fast a lid’s seal loosens.
Common questions
What is the best silicone freezer tray overall?
The Souper Cubes 2 Cup Silicone Freezer Tray works well overall because its molded volume markings turn soup or sauce into pre-measured portions.
Are silicone freezer trays safe for baby food?
Yes, trays marketed for baby food, including the OXO Tot and Olababy trays, use BPA-free or food-grade silicone rated for freezer and microwave use.
How do you get frozen cubes out of a silicone tray?
Most trays release easier after sitting at room temperature briefly, then either twisting gently or pushing from underneath the cavity rather than squeezing hard.
What size cavity is best for baby food portions?
A cavity around one ounce, like those on the OXO Tot, Olababy and Haakaa trays, matches a typical single baby food serving.
Can silicone freezer trays go in the dishwasher?
Most can, though hand washing occasionally can help a clip-on or hinged lid keep its seal longer than constant dishwasher cycles.
Is a hinged lid better than a clip-on lid for freezer trays?
A hinged lid stays attached and cannot get lost, while a clip-on lid, like WeeSprout’s, often seals a bit more tightly against freezer odor.
What silicone freezer tray works for soup and stock?
The Souper Cubes 2 Cup tray is built for this, with large cavities and molded cup markings for measured soup or stock portions.
Do silicone freezer trays stain from tomato-based foods?
Some do over time, though trays like Bentgo Baby’s are noted for resisting staining better than softer, more porous silicone.
Are two-tray multi-packs worth it for freezer trays?
Yes for households freezing food often, since a multi-pack like WeeSprout’s lets one tray stay in rotation while the other is washed and refilled.
Our take
For most kitchens, the Souper Cubes 2 Cup Silicone Freezer Tray earns the top spot by turning batch-cooked soup and sauce into measured, stackable portions. Parents focused purely on baby food portions should choose the OXO Tot tray instead, since its smaller cavities and attached lid fit that single purpose better. Anyone freezing on a budget or in high volume can skip single premium trays and pick the WeeSprout two-tray pack for more cavities per dollar.
Dana Whitfield
Dana spent eight years buying and merchandising for a regional kitchenware retailer before moving into editorial work. She has handled thousands of SKUs across cookware, small appliances and kitchen organization, and focuses on the practical differences that matter once a product is actually in daily use.
